Conclusions

Home
Up

Skies
Inner Orbit
Sept 22
Sept 28
Oct 03
Oct 08
Oct 20
Moonlight
Þ Skies

Videos
Outer Orbit
Inner Orbit
Moonrise
Halley

References

Web Map

It is tempting to speculate that calling Chanukah a "festival of lights" is connected with the "days of fire."

Megillat Taanit, 25 Kislev first mentions kindling lights in honour of the festival and links it to the previously unknown "miracle of the oil." 
Legend says that, when the Temple was rededicated, the Maccabees only had enough pure holy oil to last for 1 day, but it lasted for 8 until new supplies arrived.

Clearly, by this time, the appearance of Halley’s comet and the lunar eclipse of 164 BCE had long been forgotten.

Many sources may have contributed to the development of the new custom. The "days of fire" may have been one: pagan solstice festivals may have been another. We have already seen the significance of the 25th in various traditions.

One can imagine the Maccabees seizing on the comet as the heavenly sign that would allow them to safely light the sacred flame, perhaps even more so when in conjunction with 3 bright planets, Jupiter, Venus and Saturn.

In the absence of a fire from Heaven, surely a fire in the heavens was good enough!

The eclipse would have unsettled them -  would it also spur them to get a move on with the rededication before something went wrong?

If they looked on it as a warning that trouble from Antiochus was ahead, they would still have got on with their rededication as quickly as possible, (they didn't know about Antiochus's death). 

The eclipse happened on 12th Kislev, at the beginning of what would have been the festival of Succot, (Tabernacles), had the calendar been right.

They would not do the rededication during what should have been the Festival season, so they did it as soon as possible after the Festivals would have ended - the 25th of the month - possibly bearing in mind the other significances of the 25th.

It is highly likely that Halley's comet and the eclipse of the moon affected the date of the rededication of the Temple on 25th Kislev 164 BCE.

Is there a connection between the miraculous 'lights in the sky' and the Chanukah candles that we still light 2000 years later?